funding · Guide
How to Compare Startup Accelerator Offers: Equity, Fees and Time Commitment
Compare accelerator deals using net cash, future dilution, required attendance and the cost of founder time.

Two accelerators can advertise the same amount of funding and leave a company with different cash, ownership and calendar commitments. One package might combine a fixed stake with a future conversion instrument. Another might offer more flexible participation but less cash after fees and travel. Comparing a single headline number hides the decision.
Ask for the current program schedule and complete deal documents. Build a scorecard showing what you receive, what you owe and what operating work you can complete during the cohort. Keep assumptions and unresolved terms visible so a spreadsheet does not create false precision.
Key Takeaways
- Put investment, fees, relocation, coverage and travel onto a dated cash schedule.
- Model fixed and contingent ownership separately across plausible future financings.
- Check required attendance, founder names and locations with the specific cohort.
- Evaluate program value against an independent plan for the same period.
Read each instrument and its release conditions
Create a row for every promise of money. What entity pays it? Is it cash, an advance, an award or an investment? What documents and approvals are needed? When can it be spent? Include any conditions like incorporation, account setup or meeting specific milestones. Use dates from the written offer and clearly flag ones that still depend on review.
Y Combinator's standard deal illustrates a common reading mistake. Its published package describes a fixed percentage and additional equity from another instrument. Techstars' investment terms also describe a package containing two agreements with different effects. These are examples specific to the terms each provider publishes. Do not use them to predict your cohort's documents or compare providers on a headline percentage alone.
Read every fee separately. Ask about participant fees, VAT or other applicable tax, payment due dates, reimbursed costs, deposits and exit charges. A charge invoiced before the capital closes has a different effect from one deducted immediately from proceeds. Identify if a cash reimbursement requires receipts or specific suppliers. Confirm tax treatment for your entity with an adviser rather than treating published marketing terms as tax advice.
Build a downside ownership view
A fixed percentage gives a starting point, but the cap table may also include previous options, notes, or a simple agreement for future equity (SAFE). For each contingent instrument, record what triggers conversion and what changes the shares it receives, such as a discount, valuation cap or most-favored-nation provision. An uncapped instrument can still convert into equity. Its effect may depend on the terms of agreements issued later. Ask counsel to model the exact language rather than assuming all similarly named instruments work alike.
Request a capitalization view before the program, immediately afterward as applicable and after an illustrative next financing. Use at least two valuations or financing structures. Include the pool, convertibles and any later option-pool changes; otherwise an apparently exact percentage may obscure a material difference. Check participation rights in future rounds and any information, consent or board rights. Economics and governance should have separate rows.
Don't convert the stake into a universal dollar cost. A share of the business has a different realized value depending on future outcomes and the rights attached to it. Use the scenario to understand ownership, not to invent a price for the commitment. A fee of $5,000 is an immediate cash cost. A claim on future ownership is a different kind of cost. Both belong in the decision and neither should be silently averaged into a single ratio.
Price participation and the work you postpone
Get the calendar at the level of individual weeks. Check required live sessions and attendance, in-person weeks, office hours, demo events and obligations after the program ends. Confirm whether one founder can attend on behalf of the company, which meetings can be remote, and whether approval is required for absence. If you need visas, workspace, insurance or coverage at home, plan for those costs and lead times separately.
Calculate what the team would do without the program. A founder who is also the only person capable of installing the product cannot allocate forty hours a week twice. Estimate the delivery or sales activity that moves, who covers it and the expected effect. Time spent with mentors can be productive operating time if they help resolve the work you would otherwise do. Do not count every cohort hour as lost, or every cohort hour as useful.
Check the noncash benefits in the same way. A partner introduction is worth more when it reaches the right buyer with their consent and there is a product ready to trial. A credit is useful when the company would otherwise buy the service, can redeem it and has no costly migration. Ask alumni which mentors were available, whom they met and what stayed accessible after the cohort. A testimonial is evidence of one experience, not a promise of the same result.
Worked comparison: two offers with equal headline cash
Imagine two hypothetical programs each offer $100,000. Offer A requires a fixed ownership allocation plus a convertible agreement, takes $5,000 in fees, and requires two relocation weeks that cost $7,000. Offer B requires a fixed allocation alone, charges no fee and costs about $3,000 in travel. Assume the amounts can be spent upon closing and there are no other cash costs in this simplified example.
Offer A leaves $88,000 after the listed cash costs; B leaves $97,000. The $9,000 difference is only the cash comparison. It excludes the opportunity cost of time, future dilution under A, and any differences in support. If A includes a credible route to two supervised trials, that might matter more to the company than the cash difference. If the team has already arranged both trials, it may be paying for access it does not need.
Now suppose A's closing slips by a month, while the fee is due earlier. Put the fee and travel where they actually fall and recalculate both paths. An $88,000 net result does not guarantee the company can pay $12,000 before closing. If acceptance is conditional on spending expenses the team cannot cover, negotiate the dates or decline. Document concessions; a verbal exemption may not change a signed obligation.
Compare what happens after signing
Ask what happens if the program changes format, closes a location or replaces a mentor named during recruitment. Read how both sides can alter or leave the agreement and which obligations survive. In a hypothetical case, a founder is comfortable with a fixed attendance commitment only because three sessions will provide access to technical advisers. If those sessions move online, it may still work. If the advisers are not available at all, the company might be keeping the full obligation for a materially different benefit. Document conditions that are decisive if the provider will agree to them, and get advice on how enforceable they actually are.
Check whether accepting one program prevents participation in another or affects existing commitments. A company with a partner grant may have promised on-site tests during the same dates, even if the accelerator permits absences. A proposed investment could require consent under existing documents. List those interactions before negotiating an acceptance deadline. If a founder needs to move an existing commitment, get agreement from the party that can change it. An accommodation offered by the accelerator cannot bind a pilot customer or previous investor.
Write an explicit recommendation before the deadline: accept subject to confirmed terms, request a specific change, or decline. Include the alternative and the one or two variables that would reverse the decision. In the equal-cash example, those variables might be a confirmed trial and the fee date. If the accelerator says the trial is only an introduction, recalculate the case without assuming a buyer will proceed. Keep the written decision and the final terms together. If the team compares another cohort next year, it can reuse the framework and check which benefits it actually received.
Make the scorecard before the offer deadline
- Cash: gross proceeds, conditions, expense dates, minimum cash, and net amount.
- Ownership: fixed stake, conversion cases, participation rights and control implications.
- Time: required days, people, location, travel, and company work displaced.
- Support: named resource, availability, evidence from former participants and a specific use.
- Risk: what happens if cash, attendance or the targeted business milestone slips.
Give each non-negotiable a pass, fail or unknown label before scoring benefits. For instance, if the lead engineer cannot leave a customer implementation, an in-person attendance conflict is a decision gate. An unknown investment term is not a low score you can make up with high perceived prestige. It is a question that must be answered before signing. For agreements involving securities, get terms explained by qualified counsel in the applicable jurisdiction.
If you need help evaluating whether the timing is right, first identify the milestone the accelerator will help you reach. A good scorecard should let you state four things in plain language: what the company gets, what it gives up, what the support helps it finish and what it will do if an assumption fails. Once those are clear, differences between the offers become easier to debate.
